Execution Is Easy to Buy. Judgment Tends Not to Be.
When a company gets sued, the first thing that goes out is rarely the press release. It is a sentence. Someone has to decide what that sentence says, who says it, and what stays unsaid. Everything after that, the statement, the talking points, the posts, the briefing notes for employees, is production. The sentence is judgment.
I have watched leaders spend real effort buying the production and very little thought on who writes the sentence. I understand why. Production is visible. You can count it, schedule it, and review it in a weekly meeting. Judgment shows up as a short call where someone tells you not to say the thing you badly want to say, and that is a hard line item to defend.
I think that gap is worth closing before the day you need it, and a deal announced last week gave me a clean way to explain why.
The work that got easy to buy
In my experience, most of what a communications program produces can be bought from many places. Content, design, media lists, posting calendars, press release distribution, reporting. There are capable people and firms at every level doing this work. That is good for buyers. It also means output tends to become easier to compare and easier to replace, which is what happens to anything that can be specified in advance.
The part that resists that is the part you cannot write a spec for. You can't hand a vendor a brief that says "tell me which of these three true statements will hurt us in front of a jury" or "decide whether the CEO should speak today or let the general counsel speak tomorrow." Those are calls. They depend on reading people, reading pressure, and reading consequences that have not happened yet.
When I hear leaders say communications help all looks the same, I think they are usually describing the production layer. They are right about that layer. They are often missing the one above it.
What a crisis and litigation firm tends to sell
On November 2, O'Dwyer's reported that Public Policy Holding Company, a publicly listed communications group, had acquired Reevemark, a New York firm founded in 2018 by five former Sard Verbinnen professionals. According to O'Dwyer's, the deal adds 17 New York staff and capabilities in litigation support, transactions, shareholder activism and crisis communications.
PRovoke Media's report describes Reevemark as a firm that advises "companies, asset managers and individuals on high-stakes reputational matters," and notes that it will keep its name and operate as a standalone business inside PPHC's TrailRunner International group. In a statement quoted by PRovoke Media, PPHC's CEO, Stewart Hall, described litigation communications as "one of the fastest-growing areas of our market." That is the acquiring company's own view of its market, not an independent measurement, and I read it that way.
What interests me is less the deal itself than the shape of what was bought. A 17-person firm is unlikely to be a production engine. As I read it, its value sits with a small number of people who get called when a lawsuit lands, an activist investor shows up, or a transaction has to be explained to people who would rather it did not happen. In that kind of work, the call is the product: made quickly, under scrutiny, often with a lawyer in the room.
I think that's a signal of where the market places value: in command of the story under pressure, not in the volume of output. It does not prove anything about the whole industry, and I would not stretch it that far. It is one clear example of a buyer choosing to pay for judgment that holds its value.
Judgment tends to be a decision, not a deliverable
The easiest way to see the difference is to ask what you are left holding when the work is done.
With production, you are left holding an artifact. A post, a deck, a statement, a report. You can show it to someone.
With judgment, you are often left holding something that did not happen. The interview the CEO did not give. The admission that was worded so it did not create a second story. The response that waited a day, so the facts arrived before the opinions did. When I wrote about what the apology actually has to claim, the core of the advice was a decision about posture, not a list of phrases. The phrasing follows from the decision.
That is why judgment tends to be underpriced by the people buying it. It rarely produces something you can hold up in a meeting. Its best results often look like nothing at all.
The research on expert intuition helps explain why this is harder to evaluate than it sounds. In a well-known paper, Daniel Kahneman and Gary Klein set out to answer when professional intuition can be trusted. Their conclusion, published in American Psychologist in 2009, was that it depends on two things: how predictable the environment is, and whether the person has had a real chance to learn its patterns. They also concluded that subjective confidence is not a reliable sign that a judgment is accurate.
That last point matters for anyone hiring counsel. The most confident voice in the room is not necessarily the most skilled one. What you want to know is whether this person has spent enough time inside situations like yours, with enough feedback, to have learned what actually happens next.
Why pressure tends to expose the difference
In normal conditions, production and judgment can look almost identical. A good content team and a good strategist can both produce a sensible quarterly plan. You may never find out which one you hired.
Pressure changes that, because pressure tends to remove the thing production depends on, which is time to iterate. A campaign can be drafted, reviewed, revised and approved over two weeks. A response to a lawsuit filed this morning, or an activist letter that went to the press before it went to the board, may have hours. There is rarely a second draft for the first sentence.
Three things tend to happen under that kind of pressure.
The audience multiplies. A normal campaign speaks to customers. A crisis speaks to customers, employees, regulators, opposing counsel, reporters and investors at the same moment, and each of them reads the same words differently. Someone has to decide which audience the first sentence is really for.
Statements can become evidence. In a legal matter, what you say publicly can be read back to you later. That changes the job from "say something strong" to "say something true that will still be true in six months and that the company can defend."
The instinct to act gets louder. In my experience, leaders under attack tend to want to do something visible. Sometimes the right call is to wait, or to say less, or to let someone else speak. Making that call, and holding it while everyone around you wants movement, is the work. Gary Klein's premortem method, described in Harvard Business Review, starts from a related observation: people are often reluctant to voice their reservations during planning, and making it safe for informed doubters to speak up can improve a plan's chances. In a crisis, the person whose job is to voice that doubt can be the most valuable person in the room.
This is also where preparation pays. In my experience, much of the pressure in a crisis comes from deciding things for the first time under a deadline. The more of those decisions you have already thought through, the more room you leave for the ones you could not predict. Work on building resistance before the attack is one version of that.
A self-check: are you buying hands or judgment?
You do not need a crisis to find out what kind of help you have. You can answer these on your own, honestly, in about five minutes. You don't need to share the answers with anyone. They are for you.
- Who on my team or roster has told me "don't say that" in the last year? If the answer is no one, it may mean you have only hired people to execute what you already decided.
- If a lawsuit hit tomorrow, who writes the first sentence? Not who sends it. Who decides what it says. If you hesitate, that hesitation may be your answer.
- Does my outside help bring me options, or only finished output? Judgment usually shows up as "here are two ways this could go, and here is the one I would choose and why." Production shows up as a file.
- Can I name who owns the company's story when the CEO is the story? The person who manages your narrative day to day may not be the right person when the leader is the subject. Know the answer in advance.
- Have I paid for anyone's "no"? This is the one I come back to most. If every dollar you spend on communications buys something that gets made, you may have no one whose job is to stop the wrong thing from being made.
None of these questions has a right number. They are meant to show you where the judgment in your company actually sits today, which is often with one tired executive and a lawyer who may prefer you said nothing.
Why I treat command of the story as a leadership asset
I think leaders tend to treat communications judgment as an emergency service, something you find the week you need it. The trouble with that approach is that the week you need it is the week you are least able to evaluate who is good. You are scared, short on time, and inclined to trust whoever sounds most certain, which, as Kahneman and Klein point out, is not a reliable signal.
The better approach is to decide ahead of time who holds the pen when it counts, and to make sure that person has the access, the context and the standing to tell you no. That can be someone inside the company, an outside advisor, or a mix. What matters is that the role exists before it is tested.
I expect execution to keep getting easier to buy, and that is fine. Buy it well. Then make sure you have also bought the one thing that tends not to scale: a person who can make the right call with incomplete information, in front of an audience that is already deciding what to believe about you.
If you want a second read on who holds the pen when it counts, book a 30-minute call. Become InPhluential™.
